If You Know, You Know: One Off-Menu Classic So Popular We Almost Made a Secret Menu...

Taped to the back of the fridge, the Peanut Colada is the long-standing off-menu item regulars have ordered for years. Not to be confused with a piña colada—this one is strictly for peanut-butter fanatics.

Ingredients:

Bananas, dates, roasted peanuts, peanut butter, cinnamon, almond milk

(Optional: pea protein)

Already naturally high in protein, regulars often add a scoop of pea protein to bump it to 35g protein even higher. Fun fact: dates naturally support collagen production, and cinnamon slows the uptake of sugars into the bloodstream—so yes, it’s a peanut-butter shake with actual benefits. That’s exactly what I tell myself while drinking this rich, velvety classic. It tastes like something straight out of a 1950s diner.

Our team know this by heart, if not we literally refer to the note on back of the fridge, making THE PEANUT COLADA the most on menu (off menu) item we have. Order in person- you won't regret it!